Jeff's Pizza Shop

“The pizza and smotherella sticks were incredible.”

Carmen McNally★★★★★

Jeff's was recommended by family and boy am I glad I listened to them! We couldn't decide between the pizza or sandwiches. So we got both! The pizza had the perfect amount of sauce to topping combo. And they have a great pizza lunch special. But don't sleep on their sandwiches They may be a pizza place, but they can make a dang good sandwich! Lastly the employees! So welcoming and kind. Even made recommendations of what to visit in the area. We will be coming back as soon as we are able!!! 💚

Brooke Tyler★★★★★

Jeff’s Pizza has become one of our family’s reliable favorites, even if the parking can be a bit of a pain when you’re just trying to pick up an order. Once you’re inside, though, it’s worth it every time. Whether we’re dining in (we have a favorite booth), getting delivery, or taking pizza to one of our go‑to playgrounds, Jeff’s is a stand out choice! Their gluten free pizza is hands‑down the best in town. My kids love it, and the wide variety of toppings keeps everyone happy — if you haven’t tried Drew’s Favorite, you should. I’m a sucker for good wings, and their garlic sauce is one of tho

Teddy Breise★★★★★

At only $6.99 plus tax, you can not beat Jeff's lunch special, which comes with two huge slices of pizza and a fountain beverage. The pizza is quite good, though it is nearly impossible to eat it without a fork and knife. The sauce is flavorful, there is plenty of gooey, delicious cheese and the crust is seasoned to perfection. Two slices and a soda is enough to fill anyone up. I couldn't even finish my crusts, and believe me, I tried. Stop by for lunch and taste for yourself!

Dominic★★★★★

Best pizza in Ames. I always recommend it to people from out of town, especially those visiting three college. I've been many times and had many great experiences. Lines can be very long, especially weekend late nights, but staff is always kind and attentive. They also always do great when delivering. The smotherella sticks and cinnamon sticks are my favorite.