Tap Room

Johnny Malloy★★★★★

Our first time here. We drank more than we ate, to be fair. Food was good though and no complaints on the drinks or the price. Our server John was great.

Yoseph A★★★★★

Stopped by Tap Room in Bay Shore for a Saturday morning brunch and had another great experience. Bay Shore itself was packed, but thankfully there was plenty of parking available in the municipal lot behind the restaurant. The service was excellent from start to finish. Our waiter was attentive, checked on us regularly, and made sure everything was taken care of throughout the meal. Our group ordered a variety of dishes including the mussels, short rib and egg skillet, short rib sliders, and the Carolina chicken sandwich. Everything was delicious and came out perfectly prepared. I was especi

Yvette Diaz★★★★★

I had such a great experience thanks to Holly! From the moment we sat down, she was warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. She checked in at all the right times without ever being overbearing, and her recommendations were spot on—everything we ordered was delicious. What really stood out was her positive attitude and attention to detail. She made sure our drinks were always refilled, accommodated special requests with ease, and created an overall relaxed and enjoyable atmosphere for our table. It’s clear Holly takes pride in her work and truly cares about her customers. Service like this

Julie★★★★★

Excellent pub food in a casual and rustic atmosphere. Service is very attentive. Food portions are plentiful and come out in a timely fashion. Try the birria rolls appetizer. They are very filling and tasty. Mac & cheese bites were creamy and soft; not dense. Bavarian pretzel is humongous and soft. Crispy chicken salad was delicious and huge. Chicken was so tender on the inside and the coating was crisp; just perfect. Truffle parmesan fries are seasoned just right. Roasted brussel sprouts were awesome. The steak sandwich was nice but lacking a little in flavor. I was told the burger w