Peter Pan Diner

“Service was friendly, food came out hot, and everything tasted fresh.”

Jim “Jim B” Berry★★★★

Peter Pan recently reopened after a fire took out the old location in 2024. Walking into a brand-new version of a place that's been around for generations is a little strange, but the rebuilt space holds onto the diner's identity well enough. Food 4/5 We ordered an omelette and basic eggs. Both came out well, not overcooked, not swimming in grease. Nothing on the plate is going to end up in a food magazine, but solid comfort food. No digestion issues. Service 4/5 I ordered the wrong thing by mistake and they fixed it quickly without any fuss. The waitress came by once for follow up. Ambianc

Frank Monteforte★★★★★

Peter Pan is back after being closed for 2 years and is younger now than it ever was! Fire can’t destroy this beloved fixture. It’s more beautiful and delicious than ever. The menu is greatly improved and the execution of this diner is as good as any great diner out there, without becoming a caricature of itself. The service was upbeat, friendly and the pace matched our group’s needs. I’m so happy for them and for me.

Tara★★★

I decided to check out the newly revamped Peter Pan Diner that opened last Monday. Unfortunately, the experience felt a bit chaotic. The noise level was quite high, and the service was somewhat disorganized—my food was brought out partially incorrect and a bit messy. The bartender was overly attentive to the point of being a little intrusive, and I even noticed the manager offering a drink to someone during a job interview, which felt unusual. Overall, it might be a good spot for some people, but it’s not somewhere I’d choose as my go-to diner. I’m still interested in exploring other diners i

Mark Kline★★★★

The new Peter Pan Diner is beautiful on the inside. One minus no real space for people to wait to be seated other than a small area or outside. The bar was nice and the food and portion size was great. The staff were friendly and helpful. Can't wait to go back to try their breakfast options