Patsy's Tavern & Restaurant

Mike Eye★★★

This was our last of the 5 oldest Pizza restaurants in the State of New Jersey. Patsy’s was established in 1931 as a social club and later turned into a local favorite. This place hasn’t changed much since the Grandfather opened it with the exception of the bar. The bar and back contains simple selection of spirits. The bar has an old pay phone. The men’s bathroom is an antique. The dining room has a combination of booths and tables. We ordered the mussel marinara with a spicy sauce. The sauce was tasty but mussels were tasteless and certainly not plump. The bread was fresh but mediocre.

The honest bite★★★★★

Absolutely loved the pizza at Patsy’s! The very first bite, you can taste the beautifully made marinara sauce paired with a healthy amount of cheese. Not greasy at all, and the crust was unlike anything I’ve had before; crisp , sort of savoury biscuit-like and incredibly unique. Every flavour on this pizza absolutely pops. The service was just as impressive. The owner and staff were exceptionally hospitable, friendly, welcoming, and genuinely kind. You can tell they really care about both their food and their customers. Dave Portnoy was not lying about a rating of 9.1 I absolutely loved eve

Megha Madan★★★★★

Make a Reservation and Carry Cash!! We didn’t have a reservation but fortunately the host was able to seat us in a booth! The place has an old timey charm to it and the food was simple yet excellent! We had the broccoli rabe Appetizer, Pizza with mushrooms and garlic(great sauce and really cool thin-thick crust!) and the Tartufo for dessert. Served by a very sweet lady Eileen, we loved the whole experience. Will be back for more pizza and vibes 😊

Ari Goldstein★★★★★

Delicious pizza, unique in its pan shaped crust, which is a highlight. A magnetic bar. Excellent service. A non functioning phone booth. May this place never change. Thank you for taking such good care of our group today.