GoodFellas Restaurant

“Food, service, ambiance, free valet parking (please tip).”

Charles Defendorf★★★★★

I recently enjoyed a wonderful meal and presentation about Galleri multi-cancer early detection, organized by The New Jersey Association of Osteopathic Physicians and Surgeons (NJAOPS), at Goodfellas in Garfield NJ. I also include a picture of me enjoying a meal at Goodfellas in 2015, first of what would be many meals enjoyed, showing how this review is long overdue. I am always looking forward to my next meal at Goodfellas and now I am also looking forward to future events that NJAOPS may host at Goodfellas. Whether I have been at Goodfellas for just a meal or for a large event; thank you,

Joseph Racamato★★★★★

Haven’t dined at Goodfellas in over 20 years and it’s just as I remember it. Enjoyed the grilled pork chop with broccoli rabe and sausage! Will definitely be back.

katie Gullickson★★★★★

Wow wow wow! This restaurant is so beautiful and the food is top tier. Fresh hot bread served with a dipping sauce of oil, balsamic, red chile peppers, and white cheese when you get seated. I got the lunch special of lobster ravioli with shrimp and peas. So filling and fresh ingredients. The staff is so friendly and welcoming it really brings a warmth to atmosphere. This is the classic Italian style restaurant you need to try. I will be coming back again.

David Rosensaft★★★★★

Nice local place. Very friendly and engaged owner & staff. Good food, classic upscale -- but not pretentious -- atmosphere. Portions generous and tasty. Chicken parm quite excellent. Great fresh and hot bread -- difficult to avoid eating too much of it! Seems like most of the patrons are regulars and known to the staff. Live entertainment in lounge, a nice touch, especially for a mid-week visit. Ample parking