Sexton’s Pizza

“Pizza was next level and the candied bacon was unique and delicious.”

Paul Sheffield★★★★★

OK, this spot is awesome! No surprise Dave Portnoy scored the pizza an 8.1. The pizza was awesome - it had this great char, awesome crunch, and lightness that was perfect. The toppings were fresh and high quality. The wings and salad were great too. All of the dressing and sauces are honemade. Our bartender, Candy, was kind and really cool too. This is a must-try spot when you are in Columbus.

Jay Four★★★★★

We stopped in a Friday afternoon, easy to get to, plenty of parking. We ordered the New York style with pepperoni and hot honey, this did not disappoint, very tasty!! Great crispy crust, nice undercarriage, and minimal flop. If you’re traveling with your four legged friend, they have a pet friendly patio to eat on.

Stephanie Cotter★★

Based on reviews from 97.1 radio station, who listed this as a number one seed in their bracket, we ordered this pizza. It arrived cold. We paid an extra dollar for extra cheese. Look at the picture and make your own impression. The pizza is supposed to be half pepperoni and sausage, half chicken and mushrooms. The chicken is breaded like cheap nuggets, not grilled. Needless to say, all picked off. I didn’t even taste them. There are pepperonis on the mushroom pieces and mushrooms on the pepperoni pieces. It’s a disaster. I would rather have a cheap Little Cesar’s hot and ready than this $30 d

Splex★★★★★

Heard a lot about this place and gave it a go. My wife and I were very pleased with everything. Candy was a great bartender and the knowledge she provided about the food, concept, ingredients, sourcing and overall was phenomenal. Also she was training.and doing a killer job. The pizza we tried was paisano New York style and pesto mo town. New York was by far the closest thing to actual New York style. Great dough, does have a little flop but overall fire. Mo town isn't authentic style but it's still really good and using ezzo and caring about ingredients that they are utilizing shows it. Chill