Benny's Pizza

“The food is incredible and the service is great.”

Yasmeen★

Had such a horrible experience here, I should’ve known not to even order from them when he hung up on me the first time I called. He just talks and doesn’t listen. I get my pizza and take it home and seems like they just tossed olives and green pepper on the pizza, the veggies were not even cooked. Pizza was thick and chewy. Never again

Rodney Griffith★★★★★

Benny's Pizza is in the top-tier of New York City pizza, good Italian, and regular food places. They use quality authentic Italian cheese, which many pizza places don't use, on their many various types of pizza. The service is fast, whether eating in, taking out, or for delivery, all of which I use. The Manager, Irving, and the staff, are very friendly, professional, and courteous. Also, Benny's Pizza goes the extra mile to follow any and all special instructions and requests to make their meals perfect. Combine Benny's Pizza: Great Food, Great Service, Great Atmosphere, and last, but not leas

Jolynda Elrod★★★★★

Benny's Pizza serves up great local slices with a nice crispy crust, a flavorful sauce, and a generous layer of melted cheese. The shop has a welcoming, no-nonsense neighborhood pizzeria vibe that makes it perfect for a fast slice on the go. The pies are baked fresh throughout the day, so you are almost guaranteed to get something hot right out of the oven. It is a fantastic option for a reliable and affordable lunch or casual dinner.

Bethsaida Charlot★★★★★

I called maybe 10 mins after 8 asking for a grandma. The guy who answered was super nice and let me know that they wouldn’t be able to do a grandma (I’m guessing because of the time. It was close to closing) BUT they can instead do a margarita pizza. I agreed and was told it’ll be ready in 20. When i came and got it, it was ready and they were just as nice in person. I got home and as SOOOOON as I opened the box I smelled the pizza. It smelled delicious. First bite— I was in heaven. I don’t remember the last time I had great pizza like this. It was packed with flavor. I’m new to the neighborho