Emiliano's Pizza

“Staff was friendly and the dining area is clean and well-decorated.”

Danielle De Soriano★★★★★

I’ve shared a review before after visiting with my parents-in-law, and I’m happy to say Emiliano’s continues to impress. Today I stopped in to try something new and ordered the Emiliano Special White Slice with prosciutto and arugula. I was encouraged to add a bit of blue cheese crumble, and it took the slice to another level. The food is consistently well made, the service is always great, and it’s such a pleasure to have a place like this so close to home. Truly delicious, and highly recommended to anyone in the area! 🍕Full disclosure: the slice shown in the photo is only half of the actu

Logan LR★★★★★

9/13/25 We were here for the weekend for an assembly. We ordered around 6pm on Saturday for pickup. A large pepperoni, steak and cheese stromboli, and turkey club hoagie. Everything was really great! The pizza was delicious. The steak and cheese was packed full and the hoagie was really stuffed with turkey and bacon! Great restaurant and we'll be coming here for every assembly at the Newburgh Hall from now on 😃 The order came to $48.

Marc Abound★★★★★

I love this place. It has a true Italian feel, with music playing that really sets the atmosphere. The food is phenomenal—I especially love the grandma pie; the flavor is incredible. The slices are huge, and they’re generous with toppings, never skimping. Definitely one of my favorite spots to go.

Junk Mail★★★★★

The pizza and food had that authentic old-school Italian Neapolitan feel, flavorful, and clearly made with tradition in mind. Every bite felt like a nod to classic recipes done right. The service was excellent as well, warm and attentive without being overbearing, which really added to the experience. It’s a refreshing throwback to a true neighborhood, family-owned brick-and-mortar spot where you can tell they take pride in what they do. Absolutely loved it—definitely a must-go!