McCarthy's Pub NYC

“Lovely Irish pub, good food , strong drinks & great service.”

Veronica Newman★★★★★

I went here bc nowhere else was open and it was near my hotel. In no which way does this discount the experience. I came alone and the bar was almost full however i was able to find an amazing corner spot. the bartenders were very nice and most were actually irish so it felt like the most authentic irish experience you could get outside of ireland. Regardless of that they were very nice and attentive, and there was even live music which i had been looking for during my short stay. Definitely pop in here if you’re in the area!

IDee ISee IWin★★★★

The food was - alright. It wasn’t bad but as Irish people we know it could level up tbh. Be a bit fresher. The rice was really nice, chips curry sauce was nice. Chicken wings were nice. So I’m not saying Wowzie and not saying horrible. But nice. The burger was alright just alright. Definitely can level up tbh and make it amazing. Service and cleanliness yes great. Polite staff and helpful.

Randall Campbell★★★★★

On a whim we stopped by McCarthy's as we were looking for some Irish food. This place nailed it. From the greeting in the door until the time we walked out, everyone was awesome and accommodating. We learned the entire staff are Irish adding to the experience of our dinner. Our waitress Éabha (hopefully I got her name correct) was great. Good conversation from her and some Irish history to boot. The corn beef sliders were so good that we ordered a second plate of them. Thank you to the staff and we will definitely be back!

H T★★★★★

During my week long bar hopping escapade in NY, one of my servers during my visit recommended this place and it didn't disappoint. The live music sold me on the place the moment I arrived. Very friendly and welcoming atmosphere. I was all for the vibe and glad I was able to stop by.