Rotolo's Pizza

“Amazing food, amazing staff, overall very well rounded!”

SeaJoy★★★★★

This was my first visit to Rotolo’s, and it was a good first impression. The pizza had a classic neighborhood pizzeria feel and looked appetizing right out of the box. The sausage portions were generous, the banana peppers added a nice little kick, and the cheese was melted evenly across the pie. I liked that it felt straightforward and dependable instead of overcomplicated. If you like traditional local pizza spots, this one is worth trying.

Steve Metz★★★★★

Stopped at my favorite pizza place while visiting Columbus for the night. I used to always get this when I lived here and I had to get it while I was in town. It was as delicious as i remembered it. Got a pepperoni pizza and a spaghetti dinner. Everything was great with no wait. The employee even helped carry it to my car for me as I couldn't get it in one trip. Thanks for a great dinner! I recommend this to anyone that doesn't want the usual chain pizza.

Tom Salvia★★★★★

I love patronizing this restaurant. There is a lot of good 'Columbus Style' pizza but Rotolo's does it as well as anyone, I never have to worry if I am going to get the quality and service that I expect. Support local pizza, Corporate chain pizza is bad for your soul :D Also the meatball sub is delicious, the homemade bread and sauce are so good.

Joseph Crider★★★★★

I have came here for years. I consider them the best pizza in Columbus. They are a family owned business and I support that whenever I can. I always get a large half and half Tuto/Meaty. It wasn't long ago it was almost $24.00. More recently it came to about $26.00. The last visit it has increased to almost $30.00. I can no longer frequent here but maybe once every 6 months.