Old School Pizza

“Great value, great service, and overall great food.”

Hunter Sassani★★★★★

We ordered carry out for a large pepperoni, batch of tenders for the kids and a pound of wings. The gentlemen on the phone was extremely respectful and answered the phone immediately. The order took about 25 minutes but was done early and was extremely fresh. The pizza was delicious but the wings were just ok, I truthfully didn't finish them. It's not that they were bad, just everywhere makes wings differently and some places stand out more to me so I don't want to taint the review over my preferences. The tenders were exceptional though and my kids (and I) loved them. Great value, great servi

Megan Paulhamus★

I've ordered from here for years, and the food was always great (before and after the ownership change even) but at least before they would answer the phone. You say "open until midnight" yet on a Monday I called by 9pm and no one answers, I thought maybe busy so I tried again a couple times between 9 and 10pm, still no answer. If your closing at 9pm that's fine, just update your website hours (and prices from the cipyrighted 2013 webpage) and tell people your new hours.

Jeff Mac★★★★★

Pretty good pepperoni pizza slices here. Just like they make em' in the 80's. Great to order up a fresh box of em' with the classic coke, and pop in an old VHS movie in your old school, top loading VCR, and enjoy your old school pizza with an old flick on a 70s tv. Then you're truly having an old school experience. Ha ha!

Dennis C Miller★★★★★

I was really missing where I grew up in the Bronx, New York. I had just stopped by a deli in Williamsport, but it seemed to have mainly German and Polish food. I was hungry and came in and this is actual pizza, not gas station pizza, not one of those pizza places where all they care about is the toppings but the base pizza is garbage This is true pizza, thin crust, not too heavy, the right flavors. Don’t mess around anywhere else.