Cookie Plug

“Wonderful service and delicious cookie samples along with variety of flavors”

Tara Moyer★

I guess I should have read the reviews first!!! We were in Indianapolis visiting and we had a taste for dessert and this place caught my eye….. but boy was it disappointing. These were quite possibly the worst cookies I have ever had. They all tasted the same, were rock hard and VERY SMALL!! I also never received the 2 drinks that I ordered with the cookies…. I would never recommend this place or spend the money again.

Trisha Webb★★★★★

I see people talking about how the cookies were hard but my experience was totally different. I got the 4 pack: OG, Smores, Cookies & cream, and Red Velvet. They had crunchy edges and soft gooey center. The OG was probably the BEST chocolate chip cookie I've ever had. The others were amazing too. Definitely replaces crumble in my opinion.

Zach Hose★★★★

The Cookie Plug offers gourmet cookies that are marketed to be a hybrid of a cookie, cake, and brownie. I personally felt like it was more of a combination of a brownie and a cookie - I didn’t get much of a cake vibe. But whatever it was, it was delicious! The Choc Rock is like a turtle cookie and the Good Luv is red velvet cookies and cream. Both flavors were really good! Only downside is that they’re a bit pricey. They’re about $5 and some change a piece. I’d say they’re worth it for a treat every so often.

Caleb Landis★★★★★

Ordered delivery early morning 4/24 and had zero expectations. Holy mother of all cookies! This place kills it! Snooperdoodle, cookie cookie cream and a surprise pink elephant (not sure if it was an accident/mistake, I only ordered 2 lol,) were goddamn phenomenal. And they showed up still warm?!? Picture is 13 hours after receiving. 11 out of 10 for sure!