Italian in Lake Carmel

4 places for Italian in Lake Carmel — ranked by rating and popularity.

★ 4.0+★ 4.5+Open now📍 Use my location

SortTop ratedMost reviewedA–Z

Outdoor seatingDeliveryBarFree Wi-Fi

Showing 4 of 4

🍽️

Fortuna

3760 New York 52, Stormville

🍽️

Gappy's Pizza

1323 New York 52, Carmel

La Famiglia Bar & Grill

110 State Highway 311, Carmel

Outdoor seating

🍽️

Valare's Pizza

1116 New York 52, Carmel