Italian in Sheepshead Bay

3 places for Italian in Sheepshead Bay — ranked by rating and popularity.

★ 4.0+★ 4.5+Open now📍 Use my location

SortTop ratedMost reviewedA–Z

Outdoor seatingTakeawayDeliveryWheelchair access

Showing 3 of 3

Delmar Pizzeria

1668 Sheepshead Bay Road

Knapp Street Pizza

2157 Knapp Street, Brooklyn

Outdoor seating

🍽️

La Casa Mia Pizzeria

1420 Sheepshead Bay Road