EatOutMap

Places to eat in Shelter Island

Shelter Island has 5 listed places to eat, from quick bites to special-occasion dinners. Top cuisines: Pizza (1). The food scene spans 5 Restaurants.

Showing 5 of 5

18 Bay
23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island
Bella Vita Pizza
53 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island
Commander Cody's
41 Smith Street, Shelter Island
Salt
63 South Menantic Road, Shelter Island
Vine Street Cafe
39 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island

Other cities in United States

Seattle (2350)Portland (1855)Denver (1516)Times Square (1486)San Diego (1403)Charlotte (1368)Chinatown (1364)Dallas (1140)

Shelter Island dining — FAQs

How many places to eat are there in Shelter Island?

There are 5 restaurants, cafes and bars listed in Shelter Island on EatOutMap, with addresses, opening hours, photos and ratings.

Where is the best place to eat in Shelter Island?

Top-rated places to eat in Shelter Island include 18 Bay, Bella Vita Pizza, Commander Cody's. See our ranked list of the best restaurants in Shelter Island.