72nd Eatery
Sign in to add a photo.
About
72nd Eatery is a Cafe in Manhattan, Upper West Side, United States. Price range: budget-friendly. Known for pizza. Also offers outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway. Rated 4.7★ by 663 diners.
Amenities
Location
What people say
“Both were outstanding, well portioned, and exceptionally priced.”
Reviews sourced from Google.
What diners say on Google
james amster★★★★★This great fast casual spot features the BEST rotisserie chicken. They also have great smoothies and nice desserts. Extremely warm customer service (shoutout to Johnny). They have self serve drinks. I haven’t tried the pizza but it looks good. Can’t wait to have the chicken again
Jonte Myers★★★★★Stopped in for a meal and was pleasantly surprised by how much this place offers. It’s conveniently located with a warm, relaxed atmosphere and friendly, attentive service. The menu has something for everyone, fresh pizzas, burgers, rotisserie chicken, salads, sandwiches, and a full bakery and coffee corner. Prices are very affordable, a solid, satisfying meal runs around sixteen dollars plus tax, which makes it an easy choice for a casual lunch or dinner. Generous portions, great quality, and a cozy vibe make this a spot I’d definitely visit again.
Liam Davis★★★★★As a guy who likes finding solid fast casual spots, I was really impressed with this place. I stopped in and tried the rotisserie chicken, and it honestly lived up to the hype—super juicy, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The menu has a lot of variety too, so there’s something for everyone, and everything looked fresh and well-prepared. The staff were genuinely friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better, and the whole place had a relaxed, comfortable vibe. It’s the kind of spot you can come back to regularly, and I already know I’ll be back again soon.
Viggy Vanchi★★★★★Great little deli style option for sandwiches, breakfast, and coffee. I stopped by here with a few friends for brunch. We all got different omelettes, which came with home/regular fries, buttered toast, and the omelette itself. I wasn't the biggest fan of the lox omelette, but the Florentine omelette tasted great. They do have a restroom in the back, and adequate seating.
Reviews sourced from Google.
Reviews
No reviews yet — be the first to review 72nd Eatery.



