EatOutMap

Marcello's Pizza

Restaurant in York

RestaurantItalianPizza4.3 (595 reviews)inexpensive

Sign in to add a photo.

Known for:pizza

About

Located in York, United States, Marcello's Pizza is a Restaurant. Known for pizza. Cuisine: Italian, Pizza. It stays open late, until 22:00. Price range: budget-friendly. Rated 4.3★ from 595 reviews, it is among the best-reviewed spots in York.

What diners mention

  • Value for money2
  • Cleanliness2
  • Food quality2

Frequently asked questions

Where is Marcello's Pizza?+

Marcello's Pizza is located at 7 South George Street, York, York.

What kind of place is Marcello's Pizza?+

Marcello's Pizza is a Restaurant in York serving Italian, Pizza.

What are Marcello's Pizza's opening hours?+

Marcello's Pizza is closed on Sunday. Marcello's Pizza stays open late, until 22:00.

Is Marcello's Pizza open on Sundays?+

No, Marcello's Pizza is closed on Sundays.

How expensive is Marcello's Pizza?+

Marcello's Pizza is generally budget-friendly.

Location

Hungry for more? Browse our dining guides or explore all places to eat in York.

What people say

The food was a bit overcooked, but other than that it was a good experience.

Reviews sourced from Google.

What diners say on Google

Brian Martini★★★★★

We just live Marcello's pizza. They don't deliver to our address, so we go and eat at restaurant. The place is spotless. The condiments were all clean to the touch. A big pet peeve of mine. We will continue to come downtown for their delicious food.

Nigar Bayramzade

‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️I stopped here couple of days ago this was by far the wost food I have ever been served. The smell alone was enough to make me lose my appetite it had a strong, rotten, almost sour odor like something that had gone bad. It was absolutely unacceptable.The taste was even worse. One bite was enough to realize the ingredients were not fresh. It tasted old, poorly prepared, and completely flavorless in the worst possible way. The texture was off, and everything about it felt low quality.I genuinely regret spending money here. This was not just bad food it was inedible. I could not finish

Ryan★★★★

Walking into Marcello’s is like being teleported to the 1990’s. The menu sign is probably the same one they’ve had since they opened, and the restaurant looks and smells like your classic mom and pop pizza shop. I only ordered a slice of cheese pizza as a snack, so I can’t speak for their whole menu. The slice was okay. The crust, a bit hard for my liking. The prices, although not from the 90’s, were very reasonable!

Christine Harlacher★★★

We ordered two slices of pepperoni pizza. They took cheese pizza that had been sitting out on the counter for a while and added pepperoni. After they reheated it, it was hard and a little burnt. We weren't able to eat any of the crust, as it was as hard as a rock.

Reviews sourced from Google.

Reviews

No reviews yet — be the first to review Marcello's Pizza.

Leave a review

Reviews are moderated before publishing. Sign in to skip moderation.

Other locations

Similar places to eat

More places to eat in York