The Cider Mill

Stewart Nicholson★

The new owners have really ruined this place. Used to be able to stop and get some cider, donuts, candy apples and maybe some pie for a somewhat reasonable price. Now the prices are ridiculous and it looks like a flea market in there with all the junk they are trying to make a money grab off from kids. If you really want reasonably priced and delicious pastries drive down 26 to Country Wagon. It's not full of all the nonsense Cider Mill has become. Very disappointing.

Jonathon Gregor★★★★★

First donuts of the season. So soft and fresh. I love the daily specials. Found out the strudel/turnover style pastries are on the weekend for specials. Good to know. There's so many new items to see now too, lots of jams, jellies and preserves that I want to try. As well as some local seasonings and sauces for BBQ season. Most importantly the most anticipated item of the year might come in June, their delicious cider! Can't wait! You can complain about price if you wish, but at the end of the day you are supporting a LOCAL family owned business. I will gladly spend my money here for the it

RJ Striley★★★★★

The Cider Mill is an Endicott classic and a must do every time we’re in town. Their cider is delicious and smooth. Depending on the patch and apples used, the flavor changes, which is a great surprise. It’s always delicious but may be sweeter or more tart or have different accents depending on the batch. The staff is very knowledgeable about these differences and will help you navigate. The donuts are incredible. The classic flavors are a must try but get a few of the specialty flavors on offer as well. We recently tried their black and white cookie which was also amazing. They also have a var

Mary Naughton★★★★

This was my first visit since it’s been under new management. I do love that they have a lot of products inside, though now it’s more store-like than cider mill experience. I’ll have to wait until fall to get the vibes when cider and pumpkins are in demand again to get a better perspective. The donuts didn’t look great to me but then, I didn’t care for them before either as the cider donuts didn’t taste like cider at all. Trader Joe’s cider donuts taste like cider. Anyway that was on the previous owner/manager. This place has lovely items, some of them are absolutely overpriced. They have the