Caroline's

“Great food, relaxed atmosphere, and solid service—definitely worth a visit!”

Yazen Aswad★★★★★

Caroline’s Cafe is one of those spots that just delivers without overcomplicating anything. Great atmosphere, solid service, and food that actually lives up to the hype. The standout for me was the blackened pasta… absolutely incredible. Perfectly seasoned, just the right amount of heat, and packed with flavor without being overwhelming. You can tell it’s a dish they’ve dialed in over time. Service was on point too. Friendly, attentive, and relaxed, which fits the whole Key West vibe perfectly. If you’re in the area and want a meal you’ll actually remember, this is a safe bet. That blackene

Jessica McLellan★★★★★

We had a delightful lunch when we came into port on the Norwegian Star. Service was excellent and the food delicious as well as beautiful! Our favorite was the Yellow fin Tuna and greens though the Dolphin Fingers and Conch Fritters were wonderful as well. The Key Lime Pie was a must-order and did not disappoint! They even kept the chickens that were stalking our food at bay with a spray bottle. Highly recommend!

Katherine Griffin★★★★★

Food was fairly priced! Super kid friendly! I have dietary needs and they were very accommodating. Overall food was great but the service was exceptional! Shout out to Robert!

Fabianna Bonne★★★★★

A great spot with a relaxed, easygoing vibe. The portions are big, so definitely come hungry! The staff were friendly and welcoming throughout. We started with the ahi tuna and conch fritters, which was excellent. For mains, I had the Caribbean steak and my partner had the shrimp po’boy—both were delicious and satisfying. Very affordable for the quality and portion size. Highly recommend!