Five Star Pizza

“The food is very consistent and the employees all seem personable.”

Eve Alexander★★★★★

We recently relocated to this area, and live in a remote rural area. My family wanted pizza so while I was in Orange Park, I asked around. Several people recommended Five Star Pizza. I stopped in and placed an order in person. Then I went and sat in my car to send a text message. Lo and behold, it was just a few minutes later that an employee stepped outside with my two pizzas! They're fast! The family loved their meat lovers pizza. I'm a vegetarian and got a custom pizza just the way I like it.

Dee Rhodes★★★★★

Pizza is solid depending on what toppings you get. It's definitely tastier than a lot of local pizza joints. If you ever get cheese pizza, I would say double up the cheese. Also, I appreciate the people that work there. I've only had one bad experience since ordering pizza there. Everybody is super cool and I love the vibes. If you're looking for a quick bite on a Friday or Saturday night this is the place to hit 🎯

Victoria Fifer★★★★★

I ordered Five Star pizza on DoorDash. This pizza is truly 5 Star. It was lukewarm when it got here(no one’s fault) and when I say best pizza of my life, best pizza of my life. If you are familiar with Joe’s Pizza in Alexandria, Virginia then this pizza is its brother. 10/10 this is better than any chain pizza place.

Rena★★

I went to go here to pick up my pizza even tho the pizza is really good. The sanitary of the place is not the best, there was rust on the metal walls and the woman working only had her hair pulled back there was no hair ring for her hair. The floor was disgusting and they even had tiles missing on the floor!