Turn Key Supper Club

“Highly recommended! When I return to Madison, I love to check out new places, and the Turn Key did not disappoint. I had the fish fry, which was delicious. Also really enjoyed the creative relish tray and cocktails. Will plan to return on a future trip.”

Mark Buehl★★★★★

We like to meet friends for a nice restaurant for dinner. It was our first time to the Turn Key Supper Club. It was a great visit. The service was friendly and helpful picking out what to eat being our first time. It was nice to be able to get a relish try to start out. The steaks, seafood and drinks were really good. Like we like to do at supper clubs, we started with drinks at the bar before going back to our table for dinner. Overall we were all happy with our meal and service.

T T★★★★★

Turn Key Supper Club… where we came for dinner and accidentally found the cast of the greatest sitcom in Wisconsin. First, trust your hosts. When they tell you to try the pickle beer, don’t ask questions—just embrace the pickle. Somehow it works, and now I’m questioning everything I thought I knew about beer. The food? Outstanding. Every recommendation was a home run, and we left wondering why we don’t have a place like this back home. But the real stars of the night were “T” for Tanner, Simon, and Madonna. Their personalities are worth the trip alone. They had us laughing all morning and made us feel like regulars on our very first visit. And one final request to management: whatever you do, do NOT make Simon cut his hair. That hair is part of the brand at this point. It’s legendary, instantly recognizable, and deserves employee status all by itself. Let it flow! It makes him unforgettable, and now everyone needs to stop by Turn Key just to meet the guy with the epic hair. Great

E Hazen★★★★★

Highly recommended! When I return to Madison, I love to check out new places, and the Turn Key did not disappoint. I had the fish fry, which was delicious. Also really enjoyed the creative relish tray and cocktails. Will plan to return on a future trip.

Carl Rue★★★★

I had brunch with my parents. It was very busy but then again it is Sunday . We each had our dishes which were very good. We found the atmosphere to me a bit loud and quite warm. The food always seemed to come out a bit slow. But it is Sunday brunch time so I get it. If I was honest I thought the breakfast potatoes were over seasoned. Overall very nice.

Amy S★★★★★

Cool space, great service & excellent food. Loved the old building & decor. The different vintage books used as their cocktail menu on each table was a fun touch. Our server was friendly & engaging. My husband really enjoyed their version of the old-fashioned. Our dinners were amazing. Highly recommend.

Jerry Murphy★★★★★

Had our 43rd Anniversary dinner there. Had some great risotto and Italian beef sandwich, after some VERY good cheese curds. Mara, who was still.in training, was our server and did a fabulous job. They even gave us a complimentary dessert for our anniversary. Will definitely be back with friends from out of town.

Mathew K★★★★

Came here with work colleagues. I enjoyed the atmosphere, especially the bar area. Good cocktails, appetizers were good, but everyone who ordered steak felt it could have been seasoned better and charred, despite being cooked to how we ordered it. I’ve heard that their burgers are the go-to item there, so I’ll try one of those when I’m back! Overall I would most certainly return to Turn Key in the future!

Kristine Gallagher★★★★★

What a fun impromptu Friday Night Fish Fry! I had a limited amount of time, but wasn’t discouraged from waiting my turn for a spot barside. Solo dining is just fine here with its uber-friendly staff and neighborly clientele, like Cheers! Very accommodating and fun with delectable selections! ~MOMic