Mr. Z's

Christopher★★★★★

We usually rent a house a block from Mr. Zs and always look forward to having one of their amazing pizzas delivered. Love the thin, slightly chewy, perfect crust. Always very nice people working there, prompt delivery, and they’re open late. Hands down most legit pizza place on the island.

Yessi’s Kitchen★★★★★

The absolute BEST pizza on the island, crispy crust just the perfect thickness, sweet sauce, super fresh toppings. I love the “Hawaiian” with mushrooms on. Service is always excellent! The boys do a great job keeping the place super clean and knead throughout service. Love to bring my kids here after a long shift, or late after a night in town.

Karen Cuervo★★★★★

When we were in the Keys, we walked everywhere and we were constantly hungry (I guess all that walking kept us wanted more food). So, one night, kind of late - we were walking around Southard Street and needed food stat. Our eyes searching the street for something delicious, but easy to eat (we were also tired from the day) and then we see the pizza sign and we knew that was what we wanted. This is not a sit down place inside or out. They only have a few high tops outside but we didn't care, we were starving and wanted pizza ASAP. We ordered a large Tomato Pie and Cheese pizzas. It did t

Salty Boss★★★★★

**5 stars – Outstanding NY-style thin-crust pizza in the heart of Key West!** If you’re in Key West and craving a solid slice (or a whole pie), **Mr. Z’s at 501 Southard St** is an absolute must. I stopped in late one night after a long day on Duval Street, and I’m so glad I did. They specialize in traditional New York-style thin-crust pizza, and they deliver it hot, fresh, and loaded every time. I ordered a large 18" cheese pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms ($19 base + $3 per topping). The crust was perfectly thin with just the right amount of chew and a lightly crisp edge — classic NY sty