Malachy's Irish Bar

“Attentive bartenders .. nice pours and a great unpretentious vibe.”

Kelly Kleinvachter★

Tiny hole in the wall. Nothing exciting about this atmosphere . Pastrami not available by 2 PM. They change out the menu so it’s not even on the menu. Two types of chicken sandwich: one spicy one says grilled, the only difference is the “spicy“ has a few jalapeño peppers on it. Not a spicy breading like most restaurants. When I asked for extra peppers they said it was an extra two dollars! It was an extremely blah sandwich I would never order it again. I had to use my friend’s tartar sauce just to give it some flavor. I have never heard of a restaurant not giving you a glass of water consider

Jake Atkinson★★

Unfortunately, I'm disappointed here. We were in NYC ten years ago in 2016 and the corned beef sandwich was so good that we saved the location in case we ever made it back. We travelled across Brooklyn specifically for that sandwich but the service was terrible. We did get to order a couple beers but eventually asked to check out (after over 20 minutes) without ever getting the opportunity to order food. I don't know if their corned beef sandwich is as good as I remember but they need to do better at giving you an opportunity to find out. Side note, $18 for two small Miller Lights seemed

Nima Emam★★

Had to stumble into this bar after a rain storm in central park. Our party of 7 received horrible service. All of us were hungry and ordered food, cocktails and beer. Yet got hit with, "we dont serve water". I get their concern with people watching the game for long hours but we were there for a quick bite only. The bar food is not bad though

Colton Ginn★

My fiancée and I came here to watch the Knicks game. Got there early before the game and found seats at the bar easily. Wasn’t busy at all. We were never greeted or asked what we would like. The only time we were acknowledged was when I was asked if I was a Yankees fan. We were never served. Walked out and went somewhere else. Might try again another time but wasn’t a great first impression.