Pizza Pie Cafe

Pukas Perfect Perspective★★★★

As a value proposition, Pizza Pie Cafe executes its business model with admirable efficiency, even if the culinary execution leaves much to be desired. Architecturally and operationally, the establishment hits all the right notes; the atmosphere is engaging, the interior is immaculately maintained, and the service is top-notch—characterized by a quick, reliable, and genuinely friendly staff. Furthermore, the expansive beverage curation provides a welcome depth of choice. However, anyone crossing the threshold must recalibrate their gastronomic expectations, as the food itself is firmly mediocr

Tj Mathias★★★

The food was sort of the definition of OK. I've been to another Pizza Pie Cafe in Rexburg that feels like their pizza was better quality. Every time I went up to the buffet for more pizza, 2/3 of the trays were empty, which just left me wishing I could have the pizza listed on the label. There was food all over the floor and overly loud. I am usually a very positive restaurant reviewer. It wasn't the worst, but like I said, it was all just OK.

Noah Lloyd★★★★

This pizza pie Café location is so much better than the Rexburg location. My wife and I came late at night to enjoy some pizza buffet but this time the pizza was tasting absolutely delicious. More than it ever has in Rexburg. The pizza tasted pretty fresh, considering it was a buffet. A few things that tasted like they had been sitting out for a while for example, there were these Oreo knot looking things and they looked delicious but then when we tasted them, they tasted stale and like they had been sitting out for a long time. The pizzas that I would say are definite must: The combo pizza,

Destinee★★★

I suggest coming at opening time, the pizza is the most fresh! I really enjoy the pizza when it is most fresh, but because it's an all you can eat buffet sometimes the pizza stays under the lamp and just gets real dry... I really enjoy their salad bar and the pasta bar! They have good options to choose from, and not only do the have regular pizza but they have dessert ones too! I'd recommend it to anyone to at least try it!