Fatfish

“Great food, friendly staff that was attentive fantastic atmosphere.”

Grace Paliseno★★★★★

We recently tried the Tapas & Wine Special and were blown away by both the quality and value. For $79, we enjoyed a bottle of wine and three tapas, making it the perfect date night on the water. Our favorites were the Tuna Tostada, Steak Skewers, and the Artisan Cheese Board. Each dish was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. We also ordered a few cocktails, and they were absolutely amazing. What really made the experience stand out was the staff. Everyone was so friendly, welcoming, and attentive. It’s rare to find a restaurant with great food, great drinks, and service that goes ab

Rebecca Senisi-Leach★★★★★

The food was amazing. We went to celebrate my first mother day and the atmosphere couldn’t have been better. My 10 month old daughter loved trying lobster for the first time. The wait staff was so accommodating. If you are in Bay Shore and want amazing food and service look no further.

Lisa Factor-Espo★★★★★

Fat Fish in Bay Shore is OPEN! We had such a great experience; walking in greeted by two hostess, then escorted to a table right on the water with a fantastic view. The general manager introduced himself, Zach who explained how he rejoined the Fat Fish team once again only this time as the GM. Our server, Jordan was attentive, personable and professional. Josh came out from the kitchen to our table along with bartender Lourdes showing me the bottle of wine that I inquired about. Happy Fat Fish is open for the season. We will be back and bringing in some friends next time. Cheers 🥂 to Bria

Johnny Bean★★★★★

We came for a late lunch. Food was excellent and view was wonderful. But I wrote this review to mention that the service was exceptional. Our waitress was named Peyton and she couldn't have been more attentive. It was a wonderful lunch.