Mill Basin Bagel Cafe

“The staff are friendly, quick and they have really fresh ingredients.”

zubair ali★★★★

Perfect spot for Bagel 🥯 😋 lover its awsome fresh Bagels 🥯 of your choice I got tosted Bagel 🥯 its bit over toasted and ruined my taste but tho I love that place price are very reasonable clean hygienic environment and the best thing is tasty quick pickup point u have to wait in busy time some times but its ok to have tasty Bagel 🥯 its worth it i hope next time my order is perfect 😅🤣 and as well coffee ks fantastic

Joie P. G★

Please do not eat here. My family has lived in milbasin for 3 generations, after growing up here i married into New Jersey. As a teenager and young adult I really got to enjoy old and new milbasin. I remember when this bagel store first opened up and my mother ordering bagels by the dozens. This store use to be so busy, like lines outside the door. I am sure the original owner has sold the store! I stopped by this past Saturday 1/31/2026, it was the worst experience I’ve ever had in Milbasin. I ordered a breakfast sandwich and a lunch salad. I walked in I said good morning, no one replied nor

Ice Cold★★

Go someplace else. It's as if they went out of their way to make a lousy sandwich. Really, nothing says I don't give a crap like ruining a scrambled egg with cheese. Are they cutting costs by using a single pigeon egg? They slapped the cheese on on it and didn't even let it cook. This is Brooklyn, no excuse for this trash.

Brandon★

I really try to respect local businesses and give them more chances than a normal consumer, but to say the service was less than subpar is an understatement. I paid over $10 for a sandwich that had a single piece of bacon sliced into two halves. Normally I wouldn’t have a problem because the food is decent, but that is just outright unacceptable food to cost ratio.