Bethlehem Dairy Store

Nadib al-islam★★★★★

Fantastic decision to come here after wifey wanted some real good ICE CREAM. this delivered. They have wide selection of flavors. Wifey got double scoop on a waffle cone with butter pecan and maple walnut. I chose a double scoop waffle cone with black raspberry and butter brittle. Flavors on all are 10/10. Very friendly customer service. Definitely returning to experience the other flavors. Highly recommend it.

R Desai★★★★★

I had a wonderful experience at Bethlehem Dairy Store! The ice cream was absolutely delicious—I especially enjoyed the coconut and pineapple flavors. What made the visit even better was the excellent customer service. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and made us feel valued as customers. If you're looking for great ice cream and a pleasant experience, I highly recommend Bethlehem Dairy Store.

George Thomas★★★★★

Come early to avoid the line at this stalwart of delicious ice cream treats in an array of flavors and styles!

Megan★★★★★

I haven't been here in years as I don't live in the area anymore. Bethlehem Dairy holds many childhood memories for me. While in town with my daughters we stopped in and it DIDN'T DISAPPOINT! It was just as delicious if not more delicious then I remember. The prices are fair as well which means alot when everything else seems to be skyrocketing. I will for sure be back in again the next time I am in the area. And you should run.. not walk! And go get yourself some frozen deliciousness..... like, right now!