Lost Pizza Co. Collierville

Rela★★

Our very first time ever at Lost Pizza was 2022 and after 2 back to back horrible experiences, we never went back. Today is 3/29/26. Decided that it should be okay now, right? I was wrong. Ordered 2 pizzas, wings and cheese sticks. The wings were actually 100% delicious and perfect. The Lucille looked amazing in the pictures, but what we got was not at all like the picture (picture for reference). The Islander had an entire slice that was just a burnt crust. Then, our cheese sticks… I am not entirely sure why they were smashed down with the sauce? As the pictures show, the sauce easily fits i

Alyson Chapman★

We usually get the Lucille. So of course that was our go to. We decided to try the beekeeper because from the looks of the photo it was very appetizing. See attached. But to our dismay. It was overcooked. With no pepperoni and no honey and two sprigs of burnt basil. Sauce was dried out. The entire $25 pizza was a bust. 100% don’t recommend. Also attached a photo of the two different pizzas side by side on my plate. Very disappointing.

Melissa Feliciano★

I have been to this location a million times because I always love the food, even though I have to wait EVERY TIME because they add onions when I ask them not to (and even tell them it happens every time I order). Today, however, has convinced me to never return. I waited for a VERY long time and watched the food of all those who came after me come out before mine. No big deal, except it comes out cold and looking very much like they had a topping shortage. When I told the skinny blond guy with bad hair who doesn’t know how to tie his shoes, he said all he could do is ask them to warm it up. I

Richard Moore★

I order a large Taco pizza and told the person on the phone to make sure that the pizza had a lot of toppings on it. I could have bought 7 regular tacos from Taco Bell and got the same amount of toppings from the tacos. I remember when you bought pizza and the pizza had alot of toppings so much you couldn't eat them all. And guess what they was almost half price of the pizza are now.