Dortoni Bakery and Cafe

“Always friendly service and delicious products...good coffee also !”

Revo Jobs★★★★★

A beautiful bakery with authentic Italian flavors and ambiance. I always order my special occasion cakes from here, and Kawel, the manager, is absolutely wonderful to work with. Always a great experience!

S Jackson★★★★★

My fiancé and I enjoyed our cake tasting with Dortoni Bakery in Commack on the afternoon of Saturday 5/2/2026. The cake tasting experience was so much fun and one of our favorite parts of wedding planning. The cake and fillings we tried were delicious, and we are confident the cake will be absolutely delicious on the day of. We customized the layers with our vision and it was amazing! We will post a picture of the cake from the day of end of July.

Barry Scheinthal★★★★★

I purchased a Strawberry Shortcake with chocolate cake, vanilla crème and whole strawberries on the top with strawberry filling on the inside and cake was decorated with chocolate sprinkles. It was Fantastic and everyone enjoyed it and it was priced right. Best Bakery in The Neighborhood and even worth the trip. Go buy one Today!

Okan Kiser★

This morning, I went to pick up my order as a delivery driver. The restaurant had opened an hour late; they had accepted all the online orders but hadn’t prepared the food yet. The manager responded rudely and angrily and kicked me out of the establishment. Even though I told him I’d traveled 20 minutes to get there, he said, “If you wanted to, you could have waited since last night—it’s none of my business.” If you can’t communicate with customers, if you’re not respectful, and if you can’t interact well with people, the food you make is meaningless. Learn to respect people first, and then yo