Key West Islip Beach

George Espinal★

Ordered the Lobster Roll styled the Connecticut way and received cut up shrimp and intimation crap/lobster with lettuce drenched in some sauce. This was absolutely awful. This must have been the worst lobster roll I’ve had not to mention we’ve spent over $100 on food here for just two people. The server was friendly but the food was absolutely awful. The food didn’t taste fresh either. I would avoid and stick to soft drinks.

Paul J★

Got charged $30 for a hot lobster roll that came out cold and had no lobster on it. I asked specifically if they had a hot lobster roll with butter and they said yes, but instead we got a cold one filled mostly with lettuce. Also they sent out the wrong kind of fries.

Thomas Kempster★★★★★

Great place off the main strip of South Shore. Nice mix of straight barbecue and seafood outside overlooking the bay. Totally awesome with sun going down and Country music performed by Tom Country! Food and service was even better than expected. Definitely a warm weather gem to enjoy!

Joseph Ferrara★

other than facing the water with a drink this place is horrible! the owner is a joke and has no clue about running a prime restaurant location. the moral of his employees is terrible not trained and no customer service. he is doing business by accident! i watched this guy sitting on his ass on a busy saturday night instead of going around mingling with customers and watching his business. dont waste your $$$$. Sal needs to pay more attention to his business