Sal’s Pizzeria

“Our server was very nice and attentive and the food was great.”

Sana Abuhandara★★★★★

Amazing Pizza! Got the pesto tomato and chicken with cheese. Dough recipe is exceptional! Flaky and melts in your mouth! Will definitely come back.

Savvy★★★★★

There’s a running joke that Ithaca is “10 square miles surrounded by mediocre pizza,” but anyone who says that clearly hasn’t been to Sal’s Pizzeria. I feel especially qualified to say that as a third-generation customer. My family has been coming here since 1989, and Sal’s has been consistently excellent the entire time. This is a true classic pizzeria in every sense. From the packaging to the food to the customer service, everything hits the mark. Orders are always quick, the staff is always friendly, and the pizza is always exactly what you’re hoping for. Whether it’s a casual pizza nigh

The Hunter Gatherer★★★★★

I was in the area for work. I stopped in for a couple slices. They added any toppings you wanted and brought it to the table with your drink and a glass of ice. The staff was very helpful and cordial. The f Pizza was great and I would definitely go back of in in the area again!

Dawn Michael★★★★

Cute little old school place in a strip mall. I bet their regular pizza is great, I have to eat gluten free so that's what I got. I called the order in on the phone then decided to eat there, the person at the register was very polite both on the phone and in person. Gluten free crust is always a bit uninteresting, but the sauce was very nice. They served it in a metal pan which indicated to me they took precautions to keep it off the floor of the oven where the gluten would be. Would order from here again.