Keystone Bagels

Donna Survillo★★

Cute little bagel spot that my husband and I were excited to try. We took a nice long walk there from our house. My husband ordered the cheddar jalepeno bagel with cream cheese and I got a chocolate chip bagel with butter for me and our daughter. I get that when toasting a chocolate chip bagel, the chips are gonna melt. But there wasn’t even a hint of chocolate to the bagel. It honestly tasted like cardboard with butter. My husbands bagel was drier than a Popeyes biscuit. On top of that, the service wasn’t bad - but the staff also wasn’t overly friendly. And there was an entire table of teen

Madison Morton★★

I was excited to try Keystone as I’ve seen many people praising it as the best bagels in the area. While our food was good, overall it was a very disappointing experience, to the point where I’m not sure I’ll return. Pictures attached. I ordered an egg everything bagel with cream cheese, and there was barely any cream cheese on it. I also ordered a steak, egg, and cheese bagel with scallion cream cheese, a hash brown, and jalapeños. There was so little steak on my sandwich that I thought they’d forgotten the meat. Literally only 2 bites of the whole sandwich contained steak. Additionally, they

Em★

I ordered online. Starting off with my 'loaded home fries'. It was literally just a tub of greasy, plain bacon and potatoes. I did not spot a single trace or drop of any kind of cheese. I took one bite of a potato and could feel the grease coat my mouth. One item in the trash. My fruity pebbles bagel that I was so excited to try, was as hard as a brick. Probably stale and over toasted, the employee who gave that to me knew it was hard because they didn't even fully cut through it. I couldn't even rip the bagel apart with my hands so I had to grab a knife to saw it in half. Also got a plain bag

Kimberly Maria (Jerzygrl)★★★★★

I have only ever gotten bagels to take home for the family or a bagel with cream cheese to enjoy at the moment. Same with my daughter. The bagels are delicious. Many different flavored spreads to choose from but we are boring. I do need to go back and check out actual sandwiches. The vibe inside is wonderful. Extremely friendly employees, clean and wonderfully decorated. We love to try and figure out the movies by the photos on the ceiling. Check it out for yourself, you won't be disappointed. If you are going on the weekend you may want to order online because that line can be long. That's