McGillycuddy's

“Very affordable and good music.”

Gabriela “Gabi” Naveda★★★★★

Edward was our bartender and he was so sweet and made us an authentic Old Fashioned Sweet, the local drink you have to try! We met some locals (thanks, Paul!) who gave us great recommendations for things to do in the area. We even got the password for Don’s TV Repair lol, which is another place we’re about to visit and get some drinks. Thanks McGilly! You made these Chicagoan’s feel welcome :)

Michael Mohr★

My friend was walking towards the exit with a water in his hand and the bouncer slapped it all over him yelling u can’t leave with that. told the bouncer that was rude of u it’s just water I didn’t know sorry. they turned extremely ghetto yelling at us as we walked out. Made us feel unsafe. Would not go to water street as it has gotten unsafe to the point where some of the staff is overly on edge because of that they are treating regular customers like animals.

Breanna Simons★★★★★

Rain was the absolute sweetest bartender! We came from up north and it felt like a dive bar with the happy hour pricing and kind staff. I always come back here when we go to Milwaukee because of the FOOD!!! best bar food you’ll ever have in your life ❤️

Mitch Bentley★★★★★

Phenomenal pub to visit! I’m not from the state. Came out there this last weekend and visited multiple bars with great experiences overall. But this spot was by far one of the best spots I’ve been to throughout the Country. The staff was magnificent, fun, attentive, and extraordinary. Went back the second night and had nothing short of a great time. Highly encourage anyone to check this spot out. Tylee and Kennie were both amazing to us!