Johnny's Pizzeria

“The food is delicious and the staff makes you feel at home.”

The Terpatraiters★★★★★

Aye t̾e̾r̾p̾y̾fam ya guy finally slid up on Johnnys, lng overdue...how was it? 👇 Overall: crazy good This place is over 80yrs old n its pretty obvious why. The upside-down pies are peak thinny thins done right. Everything about these baked discs are whatcha want inna pizzer. Great neutral sauce, good quality cheese and a proper dough/crust. 0 flopper Salad app w/house italian was a green flag to start. A dub all around, will be back! All in all 8 outta 10

Q’s Reviews★★★★★

Johnny’s pizzeria is a very well-known spot in Westchester. That being said, the pizza and food were phenomenal. We got the fried ravioli and the regular plain pie with a bottle of seltzer water. It was a phenomenal. We killed the pizza in less than 10 minutes between the two of us. The fried ravioli was absolutely amazing. The one thing I will say is the service was very good but the Pizza took forever to be served to us about a 30 minute wait from when we were sitting down and had placed our order. I was not very happy with this but then again the pizza was very good.

Edward Izzo★★★★★

Outstanding pizza bridging New York and New Haven style. Super-crisp, pleasantly ashy crust, tangy sauce, and just enough cheese to avoid greasiness. If you live nearby, it’s probably your go-to; if not, you’ll wish it were.

Michael Mitchell★★★★★

Johnny’s still holds the top spot for the best pizza I’ve ever had—nothing else even comes close. As someone who’s had more than their fair share of pies, I can confidently say there’s something truly special here that you just can’t replicate. The crust alone is unforgettable—perfectly thin with just the right chew, lightly charred, and packed with a flavor that’s hard to describe but absolutely incredible. The sauce and cheese are equally spot-on, balanced and never overly greasy or salty. Every bite feels intentional and crafted with care. On top of that, the staff is always warm and welcom