Gotham City Diner

“Really solid food, great service, and a cool atmosphere.”

Fred Apfel★

My elderly parents ordered dinner from here tonight and it was appalling. First they ordered on the phone instead of the app as that’s their preferred method of ordering. I helped them prepare by looking at the menu on the website. They wanted to split the open face turkey sandwich but couldn’t find it listed. So decided that the turkey dinner would be better given the website showed it came with soup AND salad. Upon calling they were not prompted by the order taker for the salad dressing and asked if it comes with salad too. They were told no. While clearly it was included if ordering on the

Eloy Yip★★★★★

There's no other city in the US quite like New York City. It is the hub of international trade and finance with the setting for innumerable movies. Unfortunately for Batman fans, that’s not where New York’s famous “Gotham” nickname was established. The name was popularized by the writer Washington Irving in the Legend of Sleepy Hollow. Located off of Broadway in Fair Lawn, my partner and I have returned to Gotham City Diner after 4 years for brunch today. Upon entering, we got a booth by the window with high ceilings, decorated by various NYC subway signs where I recognized having spent years

christopher fornino★★★★★

Checks all the boxes and then some. Atmosphere is Nightclub meets Sports Bar meets Diner. Great fresh food, beautifully plated. Attentive , yet unobtrusive service. Extensive Breakfast menu is available all day. Fair prices, good value. I'll be back.

M Parr★★★★★

Salmon, vegies and mashed potatoes. Cooked and seasoned perfectly. Cheesesteak eggrolls. Already half gone. A new favorite.