Faye's Pizza

“Our server is excellent, and the food was quite delicious!”

Cathy Siminow★★★

For years this has been our favorite pizza!!! 5+ rating. Recently, we have gotten several pizzas from pre-bake to frozen and the best pick up or eat in. First, the crust is not crispy like it used to be. It is chewy. Then, the cheese tasted different. The overall pizza is not the same. Hundreds of people say Faye’s has the best pizza. It is a Sheboygan staple. I wish they would leave the best alone. I hope this is just a hiccup. We really miss the old way it was made. If this continues we will be looking for a new favorite.

Yo Momma★★★

Usually very good but I've ordered twice in the last month both times were issues..it's not as good anymore or it's the service considering your hiring all kids ..first pizza was pepperoni w bacon , bacon was all FAT or raw !!! It was disgusting not even edible I had to pick it off and eat what I could which was half my pizza if not more wasted so I thought well I'll try again never had such issues before so we ordered again on the online app u have , pizza came ICE COLD!u can't tell whoever made it was not happy with the tip so when he delivered it he made sure to thank my husband for the"

Shannon Goebel★★★★★

New to the area and told by MANY people to try Fayes. Delivery was fast, pizza was hot and fresh and the cracker crust was amazing. Five stars all the way around.

Jim Gibson★★★★★

Fantastic Pizza! Everything about this place was excellent! It was around 8:30 when we arrived and we were thinking it might be too late to dine in. It wasn't, as they were open until 10:00. It wasn't very busy so we were thinking it was closing time. Once we started eating the pizza, we were wondering why the place wasn't packed. Fantastic Pizza! Priced on the lower end and full of toppings. The waitress was friendly, efficient, and attentive. This was a great dinning experience! Thank you All! I plan on eating here again.