Nick's Tomato Pie

“Friendly staff, easy street parking, kid friendly menu.”

Olivia Gambino★★★★★

I am obsessed with nick tomato pie. The pizza is delicious and Eric and Watson have the best customer service! Great end to my night 10/10 recommend WILL BE BACK!!!! We ordered one slice and they gave us a whole assorted pie! COME TO NICKS TOMATO PIE

Yunong Shi★★★★★

Great pizza, great vibe! Tons of slice options—cheese, meat lovers, Sicilian, buffalo chicken—all super flavorful and perfectly charred. Classic NY fold, crispy crust, and gooey cheese. The place has a cool, late-night college energy with friendly staff and fast service. Interior is no-frills with checkered floors and stacked pizza boxes—gritty in a good way. Open late, right in the heart of downtown. A must-stop after a night out!

Charles Walker★★★★

I enjoyed my slice of Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza from Nick's Tomato Pie. My son had the Spicy Honey and enjoyed it as well. The slices are substantial, so one might be sufficient for a quick dinner. The server was friendly and let us know what is what when it came to slices. The restaurant is a little tired looking inside but, no doubt, was nicer in the past. The adjacent room with the tables feels like a bit of an afterthought. All in all though, not a bad slice of pizza!

Benjamin Wagner★★★★★

Was in town for a hockey game and wanted pizza. Pizza and garlic knots are amazing. Couldn't get to the restaurant to pick up my order, called the store to see if I could find another way to get there. Person who answered the phone, didn't get his name, walked the order a block over which was amazing. Can't wait to come back to the actual store when I come back