Tenafly Classic Diner

“The waitress was wonderfully nice, food was good and service was excellent.”

Y C★★★

First time I ate here was good but I guess you realize the imperfections the more you visit a establishment. The food seems to inconsistent. I was very unhappy with our waiter he seemed offended when I asked how much a special platter would cost. I think its normal to ask a price for something before ordering. Anyways 3 eggs scrambled and a pancake was going to cost $22 is it me or are these diners taking advantage of patrons trying to have some food. Long story short I was disappointed with the staff and didn't like how some girl with very long hair didnt have anything on it. This isn't a ha

Martha★★★★★

The Tenafly Classic Diner at 16 West Railroad Avenue in Tenafly, NJ, has been a gem in the community since the 1950s, blending classic American cuisine with creative twists. I stopped by recently and tried the Cheesesteak Burger with their homemade cheese sauce, served with fries and onion rings, and I was blown away. (I take mine without a bun) Everything was fresh and flavorful, but the onion rings really stole the show—perfectly crisp, golden brown, and seasoned to perfection. You can tell they take pride in the quality of their food. The service was friendly, and the vibe inside felt welc

Maggielicious To★★★★★

This place is so busy but we love coming here on weekends. The vibe is your classic diner vibe and the food is delicious. Service can be a little bit slow on weekends, but that’s all part of the game. They also give crayons for kids 🙏 follow me for more food adventures on Instagram at @maggielicious.to

linette feliu★★

The food was so bad. I had high expectations but was disappointed. The mac & cheese squares are cold, dry and taste like box mac & cheese and cardboard. The burger was all right. The chicken parm pasta was watery, but overall not too bad. The mozzarella sticks were flavorless but hot at least. The waiter was sort of rude and making jokes about having a lot of food. never coming back.