New York Bagel Cafe

“I prefer the one on 71st and Yale. I ordered in the app to have the order made at a slightly later time so it would be done when I got to Tulsa (about 30 minutes later). They made it immediately so it was cold when I got there and it was not the right order. The bagel they did give me was okay.”

“Best bagel in town and Q is the best. I always get the tuna salad on a toasted everything with an iced tea. Been coming here for years and it's ALWAYS on point. Get a cookie-- you deserve it.”

“I tried cookies from here awhile ago and they were great! My second time stopping in and I was disappointed. The cashier was unpleasant. The gluten free bagel sandwich was like cardboard and the cinnamon bun was dry. On the plus side,the coffee tasted good and kept me awake on my long drive.”

Karley Parker★

My family and I went through the drive through today. The young girl in the blue shirt at the drive through told us that they were out of cinnamon rolls for the rest of the day and we said okay and pulled up to the pickup window to get our order. While at the window paying, the girl was rude and had a bad attitude.. we got home and I started eating the salad I ordered , there was a curly black hair in it. So we went back up there to say something. when we went inside we saw that there was cinnamon rolls.. the manager apologized and refund my salad. He offered us a cinnamon roll but we declined because we were so put off from this experience.

Joshua★★★★★

Tried this bagel spot this morning and was not disappointed. They have a nice little area off to the side for outdoor seating. The atmosphere is A+. Cozy, strung lights, comfy chairs and tons of styles , and a fireplace. Very nice. I ordered the pepperjack breakfast bagel with sausage and it was delicious. The bagel was toasted perfectly and the cheese melted all over. Slice of tomato was an excellent add. I absolutely recommend, and if you have time, enjoy dining in.

Ron Keever★★★★★

New York Bagel is awesome! And the owners are great! I accidentally ordered pick up from the wrong location and the folks at Peoria location made my order anyway! You don’t find places like this anymore that will make this about great customer experiences vs arguing over my honest mistake. Food is great and service is top notch! Thank you!!

Olivia Burrus★

I prefer the one on 71st and Yale. I ordered in the app to have the order made at a slightly later time so it would be done when I got to Tulsa (about 30 minutes later). They made it immediately so it was cold when I got there and it was not the right order. The bagel they did give me was okay.

Casey Peetz★★★★★

Cute bagel cafe in Tulsa. I picked up a bagel to-go for my family member. It has a lot of menu options. There's lots of cafe seating and a nice outdoor patio for better weather. The patio has a water bowl for dogs so I'd guess dogs are welcome on the patio. A good amount of parking. And it's right next to a nice green space park.

Vitality River★★★★★

Best bagel in town and Q is the best. I always get the tuna salad on a toasted everything with an iced tea. Been coming here for years and it's ALWAYS on point. Get a cookie-- you deserve it.

Star★★

I tried cookies from here awhile ago and they were great! My second time stopping in and I was disappointed. The cashier was unpleasant. The gluten free bagel sandwich was like cardboard and the cinnamon bun was dry. On the plus side,the coffee tasted good and kept me awake on my long drive.

Heartwood docs★★★★★

Food is always excellent here. My favorite is the Asian salad. I used the drive-through and so I don't have anything to say about the service or atmosphere. It's my "go-to" drive-through for good salads.