Caledonia Bar

“The whiskey selection is huge and the bartender is amazing.”

Robert BLAIS★★★★★

This bar is Epic! Lucky to have found this establishment next to our AirBnB and it did not disappoint! In town for a week from southern France, we bellied up to this bar 4 times on a week long holiday. Unbelievable selection of Scotch whiskeys and Jeff, a proper bartender (complete with authentic accent). If you love whiskey, do not miss this spot. If we lived here, this would be our local watering hole for sure. You’re welcome.

Erica Spyres★★★★★

Favorite bar in the city. If you are looking for consistency, value, great service, and a community feeling, this is the place to go. Bartenders are amazing with a chat, mix an excellent drink, and have a great selection and knowledge of whiskeys.

Willy H★★★★★

Comfortable little bar on Amsterdam. Friendly attentive service. Daily happy hour special- $15 smash burger or chicken sandwich or grilled cheese/fries/beer combo. ANY beer. Burger was GREAT.

Christie Ray Harrison★★★★

Update Feb 2019: **No more food!** They sadly got rid of their food menu and only have olives and almonds now. Huge bummer! Same great whiskey selection though. UWS neighborhood gem! Really glad to have an authentic place for quality scotch on the upper west. Attended a free tasting hosted by Aberlour here this summer, and it was awesome. Aberlour rep was super knowledgeable and gave us plenty of history and context on each of 3 varieties. Tip: Follow Caledonia UWS on Facebook to get updates about tastings. I also can't say enough good things about the staff and the food. My group got the gri