Mama Lisa Restaurant

“Party of 11. Service was friendly and polite, and food was delicious.”

Jose Marzan★★★★★

The Italian food here, delicious! The food was seasoned just right and did not taste a bit of salt. Every dish we had which I attached pictures for, was soooo good. The staff was extremely friendly from when we first walked in, sat down to eat, to when we finished and left. I highly recommended this spot, even if you need to drive out of the way alittle. Well worth it. Definitely visiting again.

assita diallo★★★★★

Honestly, I love this place! The first time I came here I ordered out and I had a great experience. Everything was so good! Today I dined in and honestly, it was such an incredible experience. Everyone was so attentive and super nice. My food was just as amazing as the first time if not better! I literally had to sit in my car and write this review because I’m like the world need to know how amazing this place is! Shout out to the team that makes mama Lisa! I will be back without a doubt.!!!

Binay Nayak★★★★

A decent Italian restaurant around Shirley. The food was good. Their complementary bread is the real winner. It’s homemade and delicious. Portion sizes are good. Soups are tasty too. Worth a try. Price is decent.

Art Teacher Amy★★★★★

I just love this place ! Been coming here since 2021. Their pizza is delicious. They now have gluten free penne, spaghetti and ravioli ! Their minestrone and chicken noodle soup are so good. They have a pizzeria side to grab a slice or a nice dining area for a sit down dinner. Love their desserts. Nino and the staff are awesome. So friendly. This is the best Italian place within 10 miles in any direction ! Plenty of parking. You would never know this place existed on Montauk highway between Shirley and Mastic/ Moriches.