Bagels Your Way Cafe

John Spiciati★★★★★

The best bagels I've had in years. You can tell they're made fresh, not brought in. Their other food is great too! It is very clean inside, and the staff are friendly.

Tony P★

Do not recommend going here at all! First off, shocked how much they charge... a 3 bagel with cream cheese almost $15 (with tax)??? And a SMALL house deli iced tea thats halfway filled with ice is over $3?? Just plain expensive, and bagels are average at best. Then as a side note, as i waited 30 min on line to place an order, i watched the food being cooked on the grill, NOTHING was sizzling when bacon and eggs were placed on it. doesn't food supposed to sizzle as soon as cracked on there? Seems like grill temp was set too low. additionally, cashier did good job wearing gloves while prepar

Joseph Chiusano III★★★★★

One of my favorite go to bagel spots. They make breakfast later than most places which is very convenient. Staff is always kind and courteous. Everything is excellent! If you’re in the area definitely check it out.

Hall★★★★★

Have been going to this Bagel store for years always found staff and food to be great. Bagels are made on site, not shipped in like some others. People who used to live the area who have relocated often return to get their bagels and still enjoy them. The store has been in the same location for many years and still family owned. This store i located in Selden and often confused with other Bagel stores in the area.