Baldwin Bagel Cafe

“Friendly service and a great selection of coffee options.”

Christian “C-Rex” Berry★★

Decided to try this place. It was pretty busy. Batches of people came in and I think it was only busy because they couldn't get the food out in time. We ordered a turkey egg and cheese, bagel with lettuce tomato onions lox and scallion cream cheese, apple cinnamon cream bagel, and the sun dried tomato cream cheese bagel. All on different bagels scooped out and toasted. Plus some coffee. Now that took nearly 20 mins...crazy. the lox sandwich came with one of their sides so I chose potato salad. That was NOT good. They were a bit lite on the smear. I actually liked the sun-dried tomato cream

Dee Spence★

We have been getting bagels from this store for years. In the past, the service was good and the bagels delicious. Currently, the bagels have gotten smaller for the same price. We usually get nine bagels, and when we open the bag, some are huge, and some are the size of a mini bagel. It really is a rip off, because you can get a decent bagel at Stop and Shop for 89 cents, and LI Bagel Cafe charges $2.00. The taste has changed as well. Another big problem is that the cashiers seem to add up your order in their head, resulting in different amounts each time we go. They could be overcharging,

Lynn★★★★★

This place made me realize why a tuna bagel sandwich is sold with macaroni salad and a pickle... such a good combination. Macaroni salad was a little sweet which I didn't expect to work as well as it did. Their jalapeño tuna was amazing. Pricey but worth its price.

charles spence★

I told the cashier that i wanted a sesame AND an everything toasted with butter and she only gave me the sesame and charged me for both! Its also mothers day at time of writing this review