Tony's Pizza

“Food, service, atmosphere and even prices were perfect.”

Brandon H★

I got a Medium 2 topping pizza which was almost 20$ and the pizza was eh I guess not really any flavor and had very little toppings and the sausage had no flavor and wasn’t a normal “Ny style crust” and was over cooked. My wife got “Baked Ziti with meat sauce”, It was super watery and the “meat sauce” was just pizza sauce with sausage crumbles on top. The garlic knots were ok. Also when I picked the food up it was not hot anymore. But the end all was it made me sick I was in the bathroom for hours after eating here.

Kaitlyn Young★★★★★

Tony's Pizza is an absolute must go-to restaurant you should check out. Food is good, prices are excellent, portion sizes are awesome. You dont feel terrible after eating the food and the owner and his wife are joy to speak to and be around. I'd Recommend the AntiPasto Salad, Stuffed shells with Alfredo, White Pie, and their Calzones. You cant go wrong with anything, but those are my go to choices!

Joe Bayless★★★★★

Tony's Pizza is an incredible local NY style pizza place. The staff are friendly and top notch. The food is the best I've had for an Italian place on Fleming Island. If I could, I would give the staff 10 stars. Tonight when my family was eating, a very difficult elderly couple were rude to the owner and the girl working the register. They criticized the girl to the owner saying her attitude was bad - all because they were upset they had to pay 4 dollars more for two refills and a to-go cup, which was clearly on the menu. They were having an entitled Boomer moment and the staff handled it well

Lexy W★★★★★

This is a small family run restaurant with authentic good food. The seating is minimal but when I went there wasn't much of a crowd so I was greeted and seated right away. The food was DELICIOUS. Every single thing we tasted was delicious. The garlic knots are out of this world. The prices are very reasonable