Extreme Pizza

“Great atmosphere, friendly staff and delicious food.”

Vane Varg★★★★★

Fresh, flavorful, and the crust had the perfect balance of crispy and chewy. We ordered the Monte Blanc pizza & a pepperoni pizza, and both were excellent. The staff was friendly and the service was quick even though the place was busy. The restaurant was clean and had a cool, relaxed atmosphere. I’ll definitely be coming back & would recommend it to anyone looking for a good slice

Rocky JL★★★★★

This was my first visit to Extreme Pizza and after looking at the menu it was definitely going to be the Everest! Oh my. This was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Pepperoni, Homemade meatballs, salami, and sausage with mozzarella. Cooked perfectly and it was still hot when I got home. Polite, friendly staff and very reasonably priced. I'll for sure be back and if you're from Star or beyond, it's worth the drive to old town Caldwell!

Jordanne Najmi★★★★

I stopped into this Extreme Pizza location while passing through Caldwell and it was a great, relaxed spot to grab a bite to eat. The interior has a really cool, sports-oriented theme with plenty of TVs around the dining area, making it a fun and energetic place to hang out. I ordered one of their specialty thin-crust pizzas loaded with fresh toppings, and it came out hot, crispy, and packed with great flavor. The service at the counter was quick and friendly, though the parking lot outside was a little tight and difficult to navigate during the peak dinner rush.

Jon boy★★★★★

This place has very good pizza! It's extreme! If I lived closer to here, you probably would see me every day. The pizza was a solid 5/5, the salad was great, and their cheesy bread (spicy) was delicious. The atmosphere was cool and comfortable. The only thing about it is limited seating (smaller location), which I don't think it effects the review because that's something out of their hands. I'm just glad the food was exceptional. I'll definitely be back!