Sottocasa Pizzeria

“The restaurant is comfortable, not too loud and very clean.”

Angela A. Cox★★★★★

THIS PIZZA!!! Seriously. The whole pie. I ate the whole thing. The crust is super thin and the char from the oven is chef's kiss. I had the margherita pizza and OMG!!! We had the burratta salad and yes to all of the fresh mozzarella. If you are in Harlem, you have to go here. You will not be disappointed!

James PapáDad Darren Hicks★★★★★

Scottocasa Pizzeria in Harlem is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, you can taste the love and craftsmanship in every handmade pizza. The crust is perfection—light, crisp, and full of flavor—topped with the freshest ingredients and incredible balance. Every bite is unforgettable. The staff is just as amazing as the food: welcoming, attentive, and genuinely passionate about what they do. It’s not just pizza, it’s an experience. If you’re in Harlem and love authentic, handcrafted pizza with outstanding service, Scottocasa is a must-visit.

Mika Milan★★★★★

Hands DOWN best gluten free pizza I’ve ever had. And I’ve traveled all over and have never had a crust so perfect. So grateful to have found this place. Friendly people, service was amazing and good energy. I’m definitely putting this on my go to list.

Deana Murtha★★★★★

On the same page as all the others saying this pizza is premier. The crust is excellent and seasonings are perfect. They also give the table a spicy olive oil to dip the amazing crust in. As good as the pizza is, I woke up thinking about the macchiato we had after dinner. Perfect finish to the evening and absolutely delicious. Staff was great, efficient and professional.