Potbelly

“Recommend the Italian on flat bread!”

LEXMAN420★★★★★

really solid experience, especially for something ordered through DoorDash. The Italian sandwich was the standout—packed with flavor, a good mix of meats, and just the right amount of seasoning to give it that classic, slightly tangy Italian bite without overdoing it. The bread held up surprisingly well during delivery. It still had a bit of structure and didn’t turn into a soggy mess, which is usually where sandwich spots fall apart. Everything tasted fresh, and the ingredients worked together instead of feeling thrown on. Portion size was solid too—filling without being over the top—and it a

Meshia Hayes★

Today I placed an online order for 2 sandwiches for myself and my daughter. It wasn't until we made it back to the car that I realized they'd only given me one sandwich. I went back to the store and the cashier explained that I was supposed to go and substitute the sandwich (although no one advised me of this when I picked up my order) I went to talk to the manager about it and the guy who says he was the General Manager addressed the manner with a lot of sass and passive aggression. I wanted to let him finish his explanation but when he rolled his eyes I respectfully let him know that I didn'

Stephanie Brown★★★★★

Stopped into the Potbelly Sandwich Shop on Monument Circle and was genuinely impressed. The food was great featuring fresh ingredients, high‑quality meats and veggies, and everything tasted like it was made with care. But what really stood out was the customer service. I didn’t catch her name, but the woman working the counter was absolutely wonderful. She was kind, attentive, and clearly knew her job inside and out. You could tell she takes pride in what she does, and it made the whole experience feel welcoming and smooth. Management should definitely do whatever it takes to keep her, emplo

JOHNJOHN “Spooki Boi” Montelongo★★★★

Pretty good place, customer service was excellent.. I wanted the full experience of the sandwich, but I guess I ordered my sandwich wrong, but I did get was good.